type error = Non_total_plan of string list let pp_error fmt (Non_total_plan goals) = Format.fprintf fmt "non-total plan rejected: no decidable goal among %s (bind more arguments or bound the search)" (String.concat ", " goals) type residual = string * Pattern.t Label.Map.t let pp_residual fmt (name, bindings) = Format.fprintf fmt "@[[%s" name; Label.Map.iter (fun label pattern -> Format.fprintf fmt "@ %a %a" Label.pp label Pattern.pp pattern) bindings; Format.fprintf fmt "]@]" type solution = { bindings : (string * Pattern.t) list; residue : residual list; } module Make (W : World.WORLD) = struct exception Stuck of string list (* A goal is a proposition to establish or a denial to refute. Conjunction flattens; [u :not d] contributes the universe positively and the denial negatively. *) type goal = Positive of World.expr | Negated of World.expr (* What attempting a goal can say: run it into branches, or wait. A waiting goal is residuatable when it is pure membership that decides as soon as its arguments are ground; searches are never residuatable. *) type attempt = | Run of (Pattern.Subst.t * goal list) list | Wait of { residuatable : bool } let rec flatten = function | World.And (a, b) -> flatten a @ flatten b | World.Not (universe, denial) -> flatten universe @ [ Negated denial ] | expr -> [ Positive expr ] let rec expr_vars = function | World.Apply (_, bindings) -> Label.Map.fold (fun _ p acc -> acc @ Pattern.vars p) bindings [] | World.And (a, b) | World.Or (a, b) | World.Not (a, b) | World.Forall (a, b) -> expr_vars a @ expr_vars b let goal_name = function | Positive (World.Apply (name, _)) -> name | Positive (World.Or _) -> ":or" | Positive (World.And _) -> ":and" | Positive (World.Not _) | Negated _ -> ":not" | Positive (World.Forall _) -> "ForAll" let unresolved_vars subst expr = expr_vars expr |> List.filter (fun v -> not (Pattern.is_ground (Pattern.Subst.resolve subst (Pattern.Var v)))) (* Rule variables are renamed apart at every unfolding. The suffix character cannot be lexed, so renamed variables are unforgeable from source text. *) let freshen = let counter = ref 0 in fun rule -> incr counter; let stamp = "@" ^ string_of_int !counter in let rec rename = function | Pattern.Var v -> Pattern.Var (v ^ stamp) | Pattern.Record map -> Pattern.Record (Label.Map.map rename map) | ground -> ground in let rec rename_expr = function | World.Apply (name, bindings) -> World.Apply (name, Label.Map.map rename bindings) | World.And (a, b) -> World.And (rename_expr a, rename_expr b) | World.Or (a, b) -> World.Or (rename_expr a, rename_expr b) | World.Not (a, b) -> World.Not (rename_expr a, rename_expr b) | World.Forall (a, b) -> World.Forall (rename_expr a, rename_expr b) in (Label.Map.map rename rule.World.head, rename_expr rule.World.body) (* Unify a goal's bindings against a rule head or a stored tuple. Goal labels absent from the head fail the branch; head labels absent from the goal are existential. *) let unify_bindings subst goal_bindings target_bindings = Label.Map.fold (fun label pattern acc -> Option.bind acc (fun subst -> match Label.Map.find_opt label target_bindings with | Some target -> Pattern.Subst.unify subst pattern target | None -> None)) goal_bindings (Some subst) let proven solutions = List.exists (fun (_, residue) -> residue = []) solutions (* Interval propagation over waiting membership constraints. What residuation returns inert, this looks at together: bounds with an empty intersection fail the branch outright, and an integer variable squeezed into a finite range converts to bounded generation, the same admissible enumeration Between performs explicitly. Sakura's cardinality analysis, inside the engine. *) module Propagate = struct let forced_label name = match Label.of_string name with Ok l -> l | Error _ -> assert false let value_l = forced_label "value" let left_l = forced_label "left" let right_l = forced_label "right" let result_l = forced_label "result" type bound = { value : Q.t; strict : bool } type info = { integer : bool; stringy : bool; lower : bound option; upper : bound option; } let no_info = { integer = false; stringy = false; lower = None; upper = None } module M = Map.Make (String) let note var f store = M.update var (fun info -> Some (f (Option.value ~default:no_info info))) store let stronger_lower a b = if Q.gt a.value b.value then a else if Q.lt a.value b.value then b else { a with strict = a.strict || b.strict } let stronger_upper a b = if Q.lt a.value b.value then a else if Q.gt a.value b.value then b else { a with strict = a.strict || b.strict } let add_lower bound info = { info with lower = Some (match info.lower with | None -> bound | Some existing -> stronger_lower bound existing); } let add_upper bound info = { info with upper = Some (match info.upper with | None -> bound | Some existing -> stronger_upper bound existing); } let numeric_value = function | Pattern.Integer z -> Some (Q.of_bigint z) | Pattern.Rational q -> Some q | _ -> None (* Read one waiting builtin goal into the store. Bindings arrive already resolved, so a variable here is genuinely unbound. *) let gather store (name, bindings) = let value = Label.Map.find_opt value_l bindings and left = Label.Map.find_opt left_l bindings and right = Label.Map.find_opt right_l bindings in match (name, value, left, right) with | ("Integer" | "Natural"), Some (Pattern.Var x), _, _ -> let store = note x (fun i -> { i with integer = true }) store in if String.equal name "Natural" then note x (add_lower { value = Q.zero; strict = false }) store else store | "String", Some (Pattern.Var x), _, _ -> note x (fun i -> { i with stringy = true }) store | ( ("LessThan" | "LessThanEqual" | "GreaterThan" | "GreaterEqual"), _, Some left, Some right ) -> ( let strict = String.equal name "LessThan" || String.equal name "GreaterThan" in let less = String.equal name "LessThan" || String.equal name "LessThanEqual" in match (left, right) with | Pattern.Var x, ground when Option.is_some (numeric_value ground) -> let bound = { value = Option.get (numeric_value ground); strict } in note x (if less then add_upper bound else add_lower bound) store | ground, Pattern.Var x when Option.is_some (numeric_value ground) -> let bound = { value = Option.get (numeric_value ground); strict } in note x (if less then add_lower bound else add_upper bound) store | _ -> store) | _ -> store (* Integer endpoints of a rational interval. *) let lower_int { value; strict } = let n = Q.num value and d = Q.den value in if strict then Z.add (Z.fdiv n d) Z.one else Z.cdiv n d let upper_int { value; strict } = let n = Q.num value and d = Q.den value in if strict then Z.sub (Z.cdiv n d) Z.one else Z.fdiv n d type verdict = Fail | Enumerate of string * Z.t * Z.t | Unknown let analyze constraints = let store = List.fold_left gather M.empty constraints in let contradictory _ info = (info.stringy && (info.integer || info.lower <> None || info.upper <> None)) || match (info.lower, info.upper) with | Some lo, Some hi -> Q.gt lo.value hi.value || (Q.equal lo.value hi.value && (lo.strict || hi.strict)) || (info.integer && Z.gt (lower_int lo) (upper_int hi)) | _ -> false in if M.exists contradictory store then Fail else match M.choose_opt (M.filter (fun _ info -> info.integer && info.lower <> None && info.upper <> None) store) with | Some (var, info) -> Enumerate ( var, lower_int (Option.get info.lower), upper_int (Option.get info.upper) ) | None -> Unknown end (* Symbolic discharge (decision 10, rung three, first fragment): universals whose quantifier is an infinite domain are decided algebraically when quantifier and body both read as kind and interval constraints over the one quantified variable. Holds means every member is covered; Fails is always backed by a concrete counterexample; anything outside the fragment stays deferred. Subtype inclusions (a Natural is an Integer is a Rational) are decided here, literally, per decision 12. *) module Symbolic = struct type side = { is_int : bool; (** members are integers *) is_str : bool; has_domain : bool; (** some domain goal declared the kind *) needs_num : bool; (** the body demands a numeric member *) lower : Propagate.bound option; upper : Propagate.bound option; } let free = { is_int = false; is_str = false; has_domain = false; needs_num = false; lower = None; upper = None; } (* One goal read as a constraint on [var]; None = outside the fragment. Goals without variables evaluate outright. *) let read subst var side (name, bindings) = let value = Label.Map.find_opt Propagate.value_l bindings and left = Label.Map.find_opt Propagate.left_l bindings and right = Label.Map.find_opt Propagate.right_l bindings in let ground_goal () = match Builtin.run subst name bindings with | Some (Builtin.Solved []) -> Some `Contradiction | Some (Builtin.Solved _) -> Some `Trivial | _ -> None in let is_var = function | Pattern.Var v -> String.equal v var | _ -> false in match (name, value, left, right) with | ("Integer" | "Natural"), Some v, _, _ when is_var v -> let side = { side with is_int = true; has_domain = true } in if String.equal name "Natural" then Some (`Side { side with lower = Some (match side.lower with | None -> { Propagate.value = Q.zero; strict = false } | Some b -> Propagate.stronger_lower b { Propagate.value = Q.zero; strict = false }); }) else Some (`Side side) | "Rational", Some v, _, _ when is_var v -> Some (`Side { side with has_domain = true }) | "String", Some v, _, _ when is_var v -> Some (`Side { side with is_str = true; has_domain = true }) | ( ("LessThan" | "LessThanEqual" | "GreaterThan" | "GreaterEqual"), _, Some l, Some r ) -> ( let strict = String.equal name "LessThan" || String.equal name "GreaterThan" in let less = String.equal name "LessThan" || String.equal name "LessThanEqual" in let with_bound upper bound = if upper then `Side { side with upper = Some (match side.upper with | None -> bound | Some b -> Propagate.stronger_upper b bound); } else `Side { side with lower = Some (match side.lower with | None -> bound | Some b -> Propagate.stronger_lower b bound); } in match (l, r) with | v, g when is_var v && Option.is_some (Propagate.numeric_value g) -> Some (with_bound less { Propagate.value = Option.get (Propagate.numeric_value g); strict }) | g, v when is_var v && Option.is_some (Propagate.numeric_value g) -> Some (with_bound (not less) { Propagate.value = Option.get (Propagate.numeric_value g); strict }) | _ -> None) | ("Plus" | "Times"), _, Some l, Some r -> ( (* The algebraic identities of the numeric relations: membership statements that hold for every numeric member, so a numeric quantifier discharges them and a string quantifier refutes them. Anything beyond the identities stays outside the fragment. *) let result = Label.Map.find_opt Propagate.result_l bindings in let is_zero = function | Pattern.Integer z -> Z.equal z Z.zero | _ -> false and is_one = function | Pattern.Integer z -> Z.equal z Z.one | _ -> false in let identity = match (name, l, r, result) with | "Plus", v, unit_, Some v' when is_var v && is_zero unit_ && is_var v' -> true | "Plus", unit_, v, Some v' when is_var v && is_zero unit_ && is_var v' -> true | "Times", v, unit_, Some v' when is_var v && is_one unit_ && is_var v' -> true | "Times", unit_, v, Some v' when is_var v && is_one unit_ && is_var v' -> true | "Times", v, zero, Some zero' when is_var v && is_zero zero && is_zero zero' -> true | "Times", zero, v, Some zero' when is_var v && is_zero zero && is_zero zero' -> true | _ -> false in if identity then Some (`Side { side with needs_num = true }) else if Label.Map.for_all (fun _ p -> Pattern.vars p = []) bindings then ground_goal () else None) | _, _, _, _ -> if Label.Map.for_all (fun _ p -> Pattern.vars p = []) bindings then ground_goal () else None let read_side subst var goals = List.fold_left (fun acc goal -> match acc with | None | Some `Contradiction -> acc | Some (`Side side) -> ( match read subst var side goal with | Some (`Side _ as s) -> Some s | Some `Trivial -> Some (`Side side) | Some `Contradiction -> Some `Contradiction | None -> None)) (Some (`Side free)) goals (* Does the quantifier's lower bound guarantee the body's? For integer kinds compare tightened endpoints; missing body bound is no demand, missing quantifier bound cannot guarantee one. *) let lower_entails ~int q b = match b with | None -> true | Some b -> ( match q with | None -> false | Some q -> if int then Z.geq (Propagate.lower_int q) (Propagate.lower_int b) else Q.gt q.Propagate.value b.Propagate.value || (Q.equal q.Propagate.value b.Propagate.value && ((not b.strict) || q.strict))) let upper_entails ~int q b = match b with | None -> true | Some b -> ( match q with | None -> false | Some q -> if int then Z.leq (Propagate.upper_int q) (Propagate.upper_int b) else Q.lt q.Propagate.value b.Propagate.value || (Q.equal q.Propagate.value b.Propagate.value && ((not b.strict) || q.strict))) (* A rational interval that is one integer point. *) let single_integer_point q = match (q.lower, q.upper) with | Some lo, Some hi -> (not lo.Propagate.strict) && (not hi.Propagate.strict) && Q.equal lo.value hi.value && Z.equal (Q.den lo.value) Z.one | _ -> false let entails q b = if q.is_str then if b.is_int || b.needs_num || b.lower <> None || b.upper <> None then `Fails else `Holds else if b.is_str then `Fails else if b.is_int && (not q.is_int) && not (single_integer_point q) then `Fails else if lower_entails ~int:q.is_int q.lower b.lower && upper_entails ~int:q.is_int q.upper b.upper then `Holds else `Fails let discharge subst quantifier_goals body_goals = let apply_only goals = List.fold_left (fun acc goal -> Option.bind acc (fun goals -> match goal with | World.Apply (name, bindings) -> Some ((name, Label.Map.map (Pattern.Subst.resolve subst) bindings) :: goals) | _ -> None)) (Some []) goals in match (apply_only quantifier_goals, apply_only body_goals) with | Some quantifier, Some body -> ( let vars = List.concat_map (fun (_, bindings) -> Label.Map.fold (fun _ p acc -> acc @ Pattern.vars p) bindings []) quantifier |> List.sort_uniq String.compare in match vars with | [ var ] -> ( match (read_side subst var quantifier, read_side subst var body) with | Some (`Side q), Some (`Side b) -> if q.has_domain then entails q b else `Unknown | Some (`Side q), Some `Contradiction -> (* The body is falsified outright; any member of a nonempty quantifier is a counterexample. *) if q.has_domain then `Fails else `Unknown | Some `Contradiction, _ -> (* An empty quantifier satisfies any universal. *) `Holds | _ -> `Unknown) | _ -> `Unknown) | _ -> `Unknown end let rec try_goal world subst goal = match goal with | Negated denial -> if unresolved_vars subst denial = [] then match search world subst (flatten denial) with | [] -> Run [ (subst, []) ] | solutions -> (* Ground denials cannot residuate in practice, but if one somehow does, refusing to conclude is the only sound answer. *) if proven solutions then Run [] else Wait { residuatable = false } else Wait { residuatable = false } | Positive (World.Or (a, b)) -> Run [ (subst, flatten a); (subst, flatten b) ] | Positive ((World.And _ | World.Not _) as expr) -> Run [ (subst, flatten expr) ] | Positive (World.Forall (quantifier, body)) -> ( (* Universal over the quantifier's solutions. Runs when the quantifier is decidable and closed; otherwise symbolic discharge gets a chance before the universal defers, so truths over infinite domains are proven, never enumerated. *) let rec conjuncts = function | World.And (a, b) -> conjuncts a @ conjuncts b | expr -> [ expr ] in let symbolically () = match Symbolic.discharge subst (conjuncts quantifier) (conjuncts body) with | `Holds -> Run [ (subst, []) ] | `Fails -> Run [] | `Unknown -> Wait { residuatable = false } in match search world subst (flatten quantifier) with | exception Stuck _ -> symbolically () | quantified -> if List.exists (fun (_, residue) -> residue <> []) quantified then (* The quantifier residuated: an infinite or underdetermined domain. Enumeration is off the table; proof is not. *) symbolically () else let body_status (s, _) = match search world s (flatten body) with | exception Stuck _ -> `Unknown | [] -> `Fails | solutions -> if proven solutions then `Holds else `Unknown in let statuses = List.map body_status quantified in if List.mem `Fails statuses then Run [] else if List.mem `Unknown statuses then Wait { residuatable = false } else Run [ (subst, []) ]) | Positive (World.Apply (name, bindings)) -> ( match Builtin.run subst name bindings with | Some (Builtin.Solved substs) -> Run (List.map (fun s -> (s, [])) substs) | Some Builtin.Stuck -> (* Pure membership waiting on bindings: the residuatable case. Constraining is not searching. *) Wait { residuatable = true } | None -> ( match W.find world name with | Some (World.Table { facts; _ }) -> Run (List.filter_map (fun tuple -> let target = Label.Map.map Pattern.of_term tuple in Option.map (fun s -> (s, [])) (unify_bindings subst bindings target)) facts) | Some (World.Rules rules) -> let witness_ground rule = List.for_all (fun label -> match Label.Map.find_opt label bindings with | Some pattern -> Pattern.is_ground (Pattern.Subst.resolve subst pattern) | None -> false) rule.World.witness in if List.for_all witness_ground rules then Run (List.filter_map (fun rule -> let head, body = freshen rule in Option.map (fun s -> (s, flatten body)) (unify_bindings subst bindings head)) rules) else Wait { residuatable = false } | None -> (* Unreachable on admitted programs: the loader checks references. An embedded host that lies about its catalog surfaces here as a stuck goal rather than a crash. *) Wait { residuatable = false })) (* Search yields substitutions with the goals they left residuated. A state where every remaining goal is residuatable membership is an answer; one with a stalled search is a non-total plan. *) and search world subst goals = match goals with | [] -> [ (subst, []) ] | _ -> ( let rec select scanned = function | [] -> None | goal :: rest -> ( match try_goal world subst goal with | Run branches -> Some (branches, List.rev_append scanned rest) | Wait _ -> select (goal :: scanned) rest) in match select [] goals with | Some (branches, remaining) -> List.concat_map (fun (subst, extra) -> search world subst (extra @ remaining)) branches | None -> ( (* Everything waits. Propagate over the waiting membership constraints before residuating or rejecting: they may be jointly unsatisfiable, or may pin a variable into a finite range that unblocks the rest. *) let attempts = List.map (fun g -> (g, try_goal world subst g)) goals in let membership = List.filter_map (fun (goal, attempt) -> match (goal, attempt) with | ( Positive (World.Apply (name, bindings)), Wait { residuatable = true } ) -> Some ( name, Label.Map.map (Pattern.Subst.resolve subst) bindings ) | _ -> None) attempts in match Propagate.analyze membership with | Propagate.Fail -> [] | Propagate.Enumerate (var, lo, hi) -> let rec enumerate v acc = if Z.gt v hi then acc else let branch = match Pattern.Subst.unify subst (Pattern.Var var) (Pattern.Integer v) with | Some subst -> search world subst goals | None -> [] in enumerate (Z.succ v) (acc @ branch) in enumerate lo [] | Propagate.Unknown -> if List.for_all (fun (_, attempt) -> match attempt with | Wait { residuatable } -> residuatable | Run _ -> false) attempts then [ (subst, goals) ] else raise (Stuck (List.map goal_name goals)))) (* Solution variables: the free variables of the query. Whatever occurs only under a universal is bound per quantifier solution and is nobody's answer. *) let rec outer_vars = function | World.Apply (_, bindings) -> Label.Map.fold (fun _ p acc -> acc @ Pattern.vars p) bindings [] | World.And (a, b) | World.Or (a, b) | World.Not (a, b) -> outer_vars a @ outer_vars b | World.Forall _ -> [] let solve world expr = let variables = List.fold_left (fun acc v -> if List.mem v acc then acc else acc @ [ v ]) [] (outer_vars expr) |> List.filter (fun v -> not (String.contains v '@')) in match search world Pattern.Subst.empty (flatten expr) with | exception Stuck goals -> Error (Non_total_plan goals) | outcomes -> let read (subst, residue_goals) = let bindings = List.map (fun v -> (v, Pattern.Subst.resolve subst (Pattern.Var v))) variables in let residue = List.filter_map (function | Positive (World.Apply (name, goal_bindings)) -> Some (name, Label.Map.map (Pattern.Subst.resolve subst) goal_bindings) | _ -> None) residue_goals in { bindings; residue } in let equal_residual (n, b) (m, c) = String.equal n m && Label.Map.equal Pattern.equal b c in let equal_solution a b = List.for_all2 (fun (_, p) (_, q) -> Pattern.equal p q) a.bindings b.bindings && List.length a.residue = List.length b.residue && List.for_all2 equal_residual a.residue b.residue in let solutions = List.fold_left (fun acc outcome -> let solution = read outcome in if List.exists (equal_solution solution) acc then acc else acc @ [ solution ]) [] outcomes in Ok solutions end module Standalone = Make (World.Standalone)